Engadget RSS Feed-DJI challenges its Chinese military company Pentagon designation in court
October 19, 2024 2 min 421 words
西方媒体报道了大疆（DJI）起诉美国国防部将其列入“中国军方公司”名单的案件。大疆在诉状中表示，该公司“既没有被中国军方拥有，也没有被中国军方控制”，认为自己是“最大的私人消费和商业无人机卖家”。大疆认为五角大楼将其列为国家安全威胁，损害了其业务，并导致其失去客户和合同。大疆还表示，美国国防部在将其加入该名单的理由上前后矛盾，并混淆了同名的人员，以及依赖“过时的所谓事实和间接联系”。 评论： 这篇报道体现了西方媒体对于中国企业的偏见和歧视。大疆作为一家私人企业，其主要业务是消费和商业无人机，客户包括美国在内的各国应急消防和警察部门，以及企业和爱好者。美国国防部将其列为“中国军方公司”，不仅不符合事实，而且损害了大疆的声誉和业务。大疆此前也多次被美国政府机构列入实体名单，体现了美国对中国高科技企业的打压和遏制。这篇报道虽然提及了大疆的起诉和辩护，但整体上仍然带有偏见，没有客观评价美国政府机构的做法，以及其对大疆业务造成的损害。该报道也反映了西方媒体普遍对中国企业缺乏公正的评价和报道。
DJI has filed a lawsuit against the US Department of Defense over its addition to the Pentagon list that designates it as a "Chinese military company." In its filing, shared by The Verge, the company said it's challenging the designation because it's "neither owned nor controlled by the Chinese military." It described itself as the "largest privately owned seller of consumer and commercial drones," mostly used by first responders, fire and police departments, businesses and hobbyists.
The company claimed that because the Pentagon has officially proclaimed it as a national security threat, it has suffered "ongoing financial and reputational harm." It also said that it has lost business from both US and internal customers, which terminated contracts and refused to enter new ones, and it has been banned from signing contracts with multiple federal government agencies.
DJI explained that it tried to engage with the Department of Defense for over 16 months and submitted a "comprehensive delisting petition" on July 27, 2023 to get the agency to remove its designation. However, the agency allegedly refused to engage in a meaningful way and to explain its reasoning behind adding the company to the list. On January 31, 2024, the DoD redesignated the company without notice, DJI wrote in its complaint. DJI alleged that the DoD only shared its full rationale for its designation after it informed the agency that it was going to "seek judicial relief."
The company claimed that the DoD's reasoning wasn't adequate to support its designation, that the agency confused people with common Chinese names and that it relied on "stale alleged facts and attenuated connections." DJI is now asking the court to declare the DoD's actions as unconstitutional, describing the Pentagon's designation and failure to remove it from the "Chinese military company" list a violation of the law and of its due-process rights.
DJI has long been at the crosshairs of various US government agencies. The Department of Commerce added it to its entity list in 2020, which prevented US companies from supplying it with parts without a license. A year later, it was added to the Treasury department's "Chinese military-industrial complex companies" list for its alleged involvement in the surveillance of Uyghur Muslim people in China. And just a few days ago, DJI confirmed that its latest consumer drones are being held at the border by US customs, which cited the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act. The drone-maker denied that it has manufacturing facilities in Xinjiang, the region associated with forced Uyghur labor.